327. Stop Overthinking Your Emails (Because You’re Drowning in Advice)
Are you stuck in a swirl of expert advice, tweaking your emails nonstop, but seeing zero payoff?
In this week’s eCommerce Badassery episode, host Jessica Totillo Coster shares a raw and relatable look at why all those “guru-approved” strategies might actually be hurting your email marketing. Inspired by a conversation with a Lounge member, Jessica breaks down the common mistakes small businesses make—like over-segmentation, over-designing, and over-testing—and why simple, consistent strategies usually win.
Inside This Episode, You’ll Discover:
Why hyper-segmentation kills data and wastes time on small lists
How to balance beautiful email design with deliverability (hint: text emails still work!)
Smart testing strategies that actually give you answers
Easy, high-impact lifecycle campaigns to re-engage your list
How to tune out the noise and trust your own data
Key Takeaway: Stop bouncing between gurus and strategies—focus on the core fundamentals that work for your business. When you stop overcomplicating things, you free up time, reduce overwhelm, and get better results.
_______
Full Episode Show Notes
http://ecommercebadassery.com/327
_______
Learn With Me
Work with Me 1:1
https://ecommercebadassery.com/ecommerce-help/
https://ecommercebadassery.com/email-marketing/
Courses & Membership
https://ecommercebadassery.com/membership
https://ecommercebadassery.com/programs
_______
Let's Connect
Website: http://ecommercebadassery.com
Instagram: http://instagram.com/ecommercebadassery
Membership: http://ecommercebadassery.com/membership
_______
Rate, Review, & Subscribe
Like what you heard? I’d be forever grateful if you’d rate, review and subscribe to the show! Not only does it help your fellow eCommerce entrepreneurs find the eCommerce Badassery podcast; but it’s also valuable feedback for me to continue bringing you the content you want to hear.
Review Here: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ecommerce-badassery/id1507457683
--------
16:28
326. 76% of Consumers Think Online Shopping is BORING. Here's How YOU can Stand Out
The Missing Element in Your eCommerce Strategy: How to Create Discovery Moments That Drive Sales
Feeling like something's missing from your online store experience? You're not alone. New research shows 76% of online shoppers feel eCommerce has lost its spark, and a staggering 79% describe the experience as lonely.
In this tactical episode, I'm breaking down exactly how to rekindle the joy of discovery in your online store – transforming the shopping experience from functional to memorable. Based on findings from the "Spark of Discovery" study, I'll show you how to create those magical moments that turn browsers into loyal customers.
From gamification strategies and personalization techniques to video implementation and surprise-and-delight tactics, you'll learn proven ways to bring emotional connection back to your online shopping experience.
Tune in to learn:
Why your customers feel disconnected when shopping online (and what to do about it)
How to recreate the in-store discovery experience in your digital store
Specific tools and techniques to reduce overwhelm while increasing discovery
Simple ways to create "happy accidents" that keep customers coming back
How to leverage customer data ethically for personalized experiences that feel magical, not creepy
Don't miss the full show notes with links to all the tools, courses, and episodes mentioned, plus access to the complete Criteo report that inspired this conversation.
_______
Full Episode Show Notes
http://ecommercebadassery.com/326
_______
Learn With Me
Work with Me 1:1
https://ecommercebadassery.com/ecommerce-help/
https://ecommercebadassery.com/email-marketing/
Courses & Membership
https://ecommercebadassery.com/membership
https://ecommercebadassery.com/programs
_______
Let's Connect
Website: http://ecommercebadassery.com
Instagram: http://instagram.com/ecommercebadassery
Membership: http://ecommercebadassery.com/membership
_______
Rate, Review, & Subscribe
Like what you heard? I’d be forever grateful if you’d rate, review and subscribe to the show! Not only does it help your fellow eCommerce entrepreneurs find the eCommerce Badassery podcast; but it’s also valuable feedback for me to continue bringing you the content you want to hear.
Review Here: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ecommerce-badassery/id1507457683
--------
20:47
325. The Goldmine You're Sitting On: How Zero Party Data Can Transform Your eCommerce Strategy
Struggling to stand out in a noisy eCommerce world? This episode holds the key.
With customer acquisition costs climbing and third-party data becoming less reliable, the eCommerce brands that thrive in 2025 will be the ones that truly know their customers. In this replay-worthy episode, I’m breaking down exactly how to collect and use zero and first-party data to create hyper-personalized shopping experiences that increase conversions and drive repeat purchases.
From the right tech tools to the best quiz platforms, plus real examples of how to use customer insights to level up your email flows, campaigns, and website—this episode is your roadmap to making every interaction count.
Tune in to learn:
The difference between zero and first-party data (and why it matters)
What data to collect based on your product type
How to leverage email, quizzes, and segmentation for personalization that actually works
My favorite tools (and the ones to avoid) for collecting and using customer data
_______
Full Episode Show Notes
http://ecommercebadassery.com/325
_______
Learn With Me
Work with Me 1:1
https://ecommercebadassery.com/ecommerce-help/
https://ecommercebadassery.com/email-marketing/
Courses & Membership
https://ecommercebadassery.com/membership
https://ecommercebadassery.com/programs
_______
Let's Connect
Website: http://ecommercebadassery.com
Instagram: http://instagram.com/ecommercebadassery
Membership: http://ecommercebadassery.com/membership
_______
Rate, Review, & Subscribe
Like what you heard? I’d be forever grateful if you’d rate, review and subscribe to the show! Not only does it help your fellow eCommerce entrepreneurs find the eCommerce Badassery podcast; but it’s also valuable feedback for me to continue bringing you the content you want to hear.
Review Here: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ecommerce-badassery/id1507457683
--------
22:02
324. The CEO Skill You Forgot You Had & How to Get it Back
Overthinking every move in your biz? You’re not alone.
I’m diving into the real reason you’re not making progress—and spoiler alert, it’s not because you need another course or a better strategy.
We’re talking about what happens when you stop trusting yourself, why imperfect action is often the best kind, and how to start rebuilding that decision-making muscle you had when you first started your business.
It’s a quick pep talk to help you get out of overthinking mode and back into momentum. You’ve got this—now it’s time to act like it.
_______
Full Episode Show Notes
http://ecommercebadassery.com/324
_______
Learn With Me
Work with Me 1:1
https://ecommercebadassery.com/ecommerce-help/
https://ecommercebadassery.com/email-marketing/
Courses & Membership
https://ecommercebadassery.com/membership
https://ecommercebadassery.com/programs
_______
Let's Connect
Website: http://ecommercebadassery.com
Instagram: http://instagram.com/ecommercebadassery
Membership: http://ecommercebadassery.com/membership
_______
Rate, Review, & Subscribe
Like what you heard? I’d be forever grateful if you’d rate, review and subscribe to the show! Not only does it help your fellow eCommerce entrepreneurs find the eCommerce Badassery podcast; but it’s also valuable feedback for me to continue bringing you the content you want to hear.
Review Here: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ecommerce-badassery/id1507457683
--------
9:53
323. How to Protect Your eCommerce Business From Trump’s New Tariffs
Tariffs Are Changing—Here’s What eCommerce Business Owners Need to Know
Big changes are coming to U.S. trade policy, and yep... they could totally shake up your product-based business. Whether you’re importing goods from China, selling to U.S. customers from overseas, or just trying to keep your margins intact—these new tariffs might hit closer to home than you think.
In this episode of the eCommerce Badassery Podcast, I’m breaking down the latest updates on Trump’s tariff changes, how they could impact your business, and what you can actually do about it.
I’ll walk you through what’s changing with the De Minimis exemption, what this means for small shippers, and why now’s the time to roll up your sleeves and get closer to your numbers, your products, and your customers.
We’re talking negotiation tactics, alternative sourcing strategies, and creative ways to cut costs without sacrificing quality. I’m even sharing how I survived and thrived during the 2009 recession—because we’ve done hard before, and we can do it again.
Whether you manufacture overseas, ship internationally, or just want to stay one step ahead of the chaos... this is a must-listen.
What You’ll Learn:
What the latest U.S. tariff changes mean for product-based businesses
How the De Minimis exemption is changing—and why it matters
Real strategies to protect your margins (even if your costs go up)
How to negotiate smarter with suppliers and get creative with sourcing
Why expanding to international markets outside the U.S. might be your smartest move yet
And why now is the time to stay focused, not freak out
_______
Full Episode Show Notes
http://ecommercebadassery.com/323
_______
Learn With Me
Work with Me 1:1
https://ecommercebadassery.com/ecommerce-help/
https://ecommercebadassery.com/email-marketing/
Courses & Membership
https://ecommercebadassery.com/membership
https://ecommercebadassery.com/programs
_______
Let's Connect
Website: http://ecommercebadassery.com
Instagram: http://instagram.com/ecommercebadassery
Membership: http://ecommercebadassery.com/membership
_______
Rate, Review, & Subscribe
Like what you heard? I’d be forever grateful if you’d rate, review and subscribe to the show! Not only does it help your fellow eCommerce entrepreneurs find the eCommerce Badassery podcast; but it’s also valuable feedback for me to continue bringing you the content you want to hear.
Review Here: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ecommerce-badassery/id1507457683
Ready to grow your product-based eCommerce business without burning out? The eCommerce Badassery Podcast delivers real-world strategies to boost product sales, grow your online store, master email marketing, and build a thriving, profitable eCommerce business.
Jessica Totillo Coster, a 25+ year retail veteran and manager of a 7-figure eCommerce business, shares actionable steps and strategies to grow the traffic, sales, and profit in your online retail store.
After building her multi-six figure brick + mortar clothing boutique and working with the top experts in SEO, Web Development, Email, and Digital Marketing, she’s spilling all the secrets like the straight-talking no bullsh*t New Yorker she is.
Every Tuesday, hear from Jessica and the occasional guest to learn what it takes to take your eCommerce business to the next level. Each episode is delivered workshop-style and packed full of actionable takeaways that you can implement in your business right away.
WHAT WE’LL COVER ON THE ECOMMERCE BADASSERY PODCAST:
- Email Marketing Strategies for eCommerce Businesses
- Social Media Strategies for product-based businesses to attract new customers
- Technical training for eCommerce industry platforms like Shopify + Klaviyo
- Social Media and Email Marketing Content ideas for product-based business owners
- Stories from other eCommerce business owners who started at their kitchen tables to build multi-7-figure eCommerce businesses
- Guest experts to share the latest strategies for marketing your eCommerce business
- The latest Shopify Apps, AI marketing tools, and software to help you run your eCommerce business
- How to use data to make educated decisions in your business and how to determine YOUR best next steps
- How to increase conversion and average order value on your eCommerce website
- How to do SEO (Search Engine Optimization) for eCommerce websites
- and a whole lot more!
If you’re ready to step into your role as the CEO of your eCommerce business with actionable steps and strategies and enjoy a little tough love to get things done, you’re in the right place.
WANT MORE SUPPORT GROWING YOUR PRODUCT-BASED BUSINESS?
Check out Jessica’s courses and programs at eCommerceBadassery.com, including:
- Email Badassery: Create a high-converting email automation system & make money while you sleep
- SEO Badassery: Get found online and drive organic traffic without spending money on ads or time on social
- Shopify Badassery: Master your Shopify store and backend
- The Lounge Membership: Access ongoing marketing & paid ad support. Includes live coaching.